2026-10-31
Login to see the interactive sport charts →
Arizona State vs BYU market analysis Oct 31: The Setup
Asset: BYU Cougars (home favorite) | Opening: $0.891 | Spread: BYU -16.5 | Kalshi: –
This Arizona State vs BYU market analysis Oct 31 opens with BYU entering LaVell Edwards Stadium as a 16.5-point favorite at 6-1, hosting an Arizona State squad at 4-3 that had shown offensive inconsistency on the road. The Cougars' opening game signal of $0.891 reflected a market that expected a comfortable home win, leaving little room for a tradeable discount on either side.
The Pattern: No Clear Opportunity — BYU's game signal never fell far enough from its opening price to generate a qualifying entry, and the brief oversold RSI readings in the third quarter arrived without a stable floor to trade against.
Going in: At $0.891, BYU was priced for near-certain victory; a meaningful pullback toward the $0.60–$0.70 range would have been required to create a long entry with acceptable risk-reward.
Who Decided It
- BYU Cougars (7-1): Sione Moa scored two rushing touchdowns and Bear Bachmeier completed 19 of 30 passes for 236 yards and a touchdown to Kyler Kasper, controlling the game's tempo despite a third-quarter collapse.
- Arizona State Sun Devils (4-4): Jake Fette was sacked five times and finished 22 of 42 for 166 yards, though his two touchdown passes to Omarion Miller and Anthony Miller briefly tied the game at 17 in the third quarter.
First Quarter: Early Dominance
Outlook check: The opening outlook for a BYU-controlled game held immediately — the Cougars forced a fumble on the opening drive and converted it into points.
Nusi Taumoepeau sacked Jake Fette for a loss of 8 yards on ASU's first play, forcing a fumble that Isaiah Glasker recovered at the ASU 29. BYU capitalized six plays later when Sione Moa recovered a fumble in the end zone for a 1-yard touchdown at Q1 10:47, pushing BYU's game signal to $0.941 and RSI on BYU's line to 85.2 — deep overbought territory. Miles Hall added a second sack of Fette at Q1 6:48, and ASU's subsequent field goal attempt was blocked at Q1 0:04, ending the quarter with BYU's signal at $0.885 and RSI cooling to 34.4.
| Time | Play | Score | Game Signal | RSI | Kalshi BYU |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 15:00 | Kickoff | ASU 0, BYU 0 | $0.891 | – | – |
| Q1 10:47 | Moa fumble recovery TD | ASU 0, BYU 7 | $0.941 | 85.2 | – |
| Q1 10:09 | RSI exits overbought | ASU 0, BYU 7 | $0.931 | 69.6 | – |
| Q1 0:00 | End Q1 | ASU 0, BYU 7 | $0.885 | 34.4 | – |
Decision Point: Stay Out — Signal Too Elevated
| Time | Score | Game Signal | RSI | MACD | Kalshi BYU bid/ask |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 10:09 | ASU 0, BYU 7 | $0.931 | 69.6 | – | – |
Known at the time: RSI on BYU's line had just exited overbought at 69.6 after peaking at 85.2 on the Moa touchdown. BYU's game signal sat at $0.931 — 4 cents below its post-score peak but still 4 cents above the opening price.
The decision: Stay out. BYU's signal was elevated above the opening price with no oversold condition or meaningful pullback to justify a long entry. The market had already priced in the early score.
Outlook for the next quarter: A sustained ASU drive converting points would pull BYU's signal back toward $0.88–$0.90, but a second BYU score would push RSI back into overbought and further reduce any entry opportunity.
Second Quarter: Overbought Extension
Outlook check: ASU did convert a field goal early in the second quarter, nudging BYU's signal down to $0.916, but BYU then extended its lead to 17-3 — the signal never approached a tradeable low.
Cade Uluave and Bodie Schoonover added sacks of Fette at Q2 14:38 and Q2 11:36 respectively, keeping ASU's offense in check. Matthias Dunn hit a 28-yard field goal at Q2 6:22 (BYU signal $0.923), and Bear Bachmeier found Kyler Kasper on a 13-yard touchdown pass at Q2 1:55, spiking BYU's game signal to $0.972 and RSI to 84.0 — the second extreme overbought reading of the game. Montana Warren then intercepted Bachmeier at Q2 0:51, but BYU's signal barely moved, finishing the half at $0.969.
| Time | Play | Score | Game Signal | RSI | Kalshi BYU |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q2 14:06 | Smith 24-yd FG | ASU 3, BYU 7 | $0.916 | 53.9 | – |
| Q2 6:22 | Dunn 28-yd FG | ASU 3, BYU 10 | $0.923 | 51.2 | – |
| Q2 1:55 | Kasper 13-yd TD pass | ASU 3, BYU 17 | $0.972 | 84.0 | – |
| Q2 0:51 | RSI exits overbought | ASU 3, BYU 17 | $0.973 | 64.1 | – |
| Q2 0:00 | End Q2 | ASU 3, BYU 17 | $0.969 | 50.5 | – |
Decision Point: Stay Out — Overbought at Halftime
| Time | Score | Game Signal | RSI | MACD | Kalshi BYU bid/ask |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q2 1:41 | ASU 3, BYU 17 | $0.976 | 85.4 | – | – |
Known at the time: RSI on BYU's line reached its peak of 85.4 at Q2 1:41 — the most extreme overbought reading of the first half — immediately after the Kasper touchdown. BYU led by 14 with under two minutes remaining.
The decision: Stay out. At $0.976 with RSI at 85.4, BYU's signal was at a ceiling, not a floor. No long entry on BYU was viable, and the 14-point lead left no room for a meaningful ASU long either.
Outlook for the next quarter: The 14-point halftime lead suggested BYU would maintain control, but a fast ASU start in the third could compress the signal toward the $0.85–$0.90 range — still not a tradeable entry zone.
Third Quarter: Signal Compression
Outlook check: The third quarter delivered the game's sharpest technical move — but BYU's signal floor remained too high to qualify as a trade entry.
Jake Fette connected with Omarion Miller on a 20-yard touchdown pass at Q3 6:30, dropping BYU's game signal from $0.972 to $0.929 and sending RSI on BYU's line plunging to 14.2 — extreme oversold. Immediately after, Kyler Kasper fumbled on BYU's first play of the ensuing drive, recovered by Adrian Wilson at the BYU 39, and Fette capped the short field with a 1-yard touchdown pass to Anthony Miller at Q3 1:15. BYU's signal fell to $0.786 and RSI touched 22.2. The quarter ended with the score tied 17-17 and BYU's signal at its game low of $0.738 — RSI at 21.7.
| Time | Play | Score | Game Signal | RSI | Kalshi BYU |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q3 6:30 | Miller 20-yd TD pass | ASU 10, BYU 17 | $0.929 | 14.2 | – |
| Q3 6:18 | Kasper fumble, ASU recovers | ASU 10, BYU 17 | $0.891 | 8.9 | – |
| Q3 1:15 | A. Miller 1-yd TD pass | ASU 17, BYU 17 | $0.786 | 22.2 | – |
| Q3 0:29 | RSI exits oversold | ASU 17, BYU 17 | $0.798 | 32.0 | – |
| Q3 0:00 | End Q3 | ASU 17, BYU 17 | $0.738 | 21.7 | – |
Decision Point: Stay Out — Floor Too High for a Long Entry
| Time | Score | Game Signal | RSI | MACD | Kalshi BYU bid/ask |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q3 0:00 | ASU 17, BYU 17 | $0.738 | 21.7 | – | – |
Known at the time: RSI on BYU's line had been in oversold territory since Q3 6:30, reaching a low of 8.9 — the most extreme reading of the game. BYU's signal sat at $0.738 at the quarter's end, its lowest point. The score was tied, but BYU still held a 73.8% game signal — meaning even at its worst, the market gave BYU nearly a 3-in-4 chance of winning.
The decision: Stay out. A $0.738 entry on BYU offered limited upside relative to the risk: the signal had already compressed from $0.972 to $0.738 in one quarter, but $0.738 is not a distressed price. The minimum profit threshold was not met. The Arizona State vs BYU market analysis Oct 31 shows this as the defining constraint — BYU's pre-game pricing was simply too high to create a tradeable dip.
Outlook for the next quarter: RSI exiting oversold at Q3 0:29 (32.0) suggested momentum was stabilizing. A BYU score early in the fourth would confirm recovery; a second ASU score would push the signal toward genuinely distressed territory.
Fourth Quarter: Recovery Without Entry
Outlook check: BYU recovered as expected, but the signal rebounded too quickly for any entry to qualify under the systematic criteria.
Matthias Dunn hit a 45-yard field goal at Q4 12:08 (BYU signal $0.815), and two MACD bullish crosses fired — at Q4 14:24 ($0.900) and Q4 5:45 ($0.871) — confirming momentum had shifted back to BYU. An 11-play, 95-yard drive culminated in Sione Moa's second rushing touchdown at Q4 2:09, pushing BYU's signal to $0.998. Carson Smith's 44-yard field goal for ASU at Q4 0:57 was cosmetic; BYU's signal closed at $1.000.
| Time | Play | Score | Game Signal | RSI | Kalshi BYU |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q4 14:24 | MACD bullish cross | ASU 17, BYU 20 | $0.900 | 62.4 | – |
| Q4 12:08 | Dunn 45-yd FG | ASU 17, BYU 20 | $0.815 | 47.8 | – |
| Q4 5:45 | MACD bullish cross | ASU 17, BYU 20 | $0.871 | 61.4 | – |
| Q4 2:09 | Moa 1-yd TD run | ASU 17, BYU 27 | $0.998 | 72.2 | – |
| Q4 0:57 | Smith 44-yd FG | ASU 20, BYU 27 | $0.988 | 63.9 | – |
| Q4 0:00 | End Q4 | ASU 20, BYU 27 | $1.000 | 65.8 | – |
Decision Point: Stay Out — Minimum Threshold Not Met
| Time | Score | Game Signal | RSI | MACD | Kalshi BYU bid/ask |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q4 14:24 | ASU 17, BYU 20 | $0.900 | 62.4 | Bullish cross | – |
Known at the time: The MACD bullish cross at Q4 14:24 confirmed BYU's momentum was recovering after the third-quarter tie. BYU's signal had already rebounded from $0.738 to $0.900 — a 16-cent move — before the cross fired. Entering at $0.900 with the game tied and 14 minutes remaining offered insufficient upside to clear the 10% minimum profit threshold on a systematic basis.
The decision: Stay out. The two MACD bullish crosses in the fourth quarter confirmed the directional move but arrived after the bulk of the recovery had already occurred. No entry met the required criteria.
Final Accounting
This Arizona State vs BYU market analysis Oct 31 produced no qualifying trade windows.
No qualifying trade windows were detected in this game. While technical signals fired — including RSI on BYU's line reaching 8.9 (extreme oversold) in the third quarter and two MACD bullish crosses in the fourth — none met the systematic trading criteria for a complete entry and exit. BYU's game signal never fell below $0.738, leaving insufficient upside for a long entry to clear the 10% minimum profit threshold.
No Clear Opportunity in This Game
This Arizona State vs BYU market analysis Oct 31 illustrates the No Clear Opportunity pattern. The pattern describes a game where nothing in the signal moved far enough from pre-game expectations to qualify as a trade — the favorite's game signal stayed elevated throughout, and the one meaningful compression (the third-quarter tie) arrived at a price level that still reflected a strong favorite, not a distressed asset. BYU's floor of $0.738 with 15 minutes remaining simply did not offer the entry discount the system requires. The full definition is on the [Patterns page](https://www.sportchartz.com/patterns/#no-clear-opportunity).
This Arizona State vs BYU market analysis Oct 31 confirms that strong pre-game pricing can insulate a game from tradeable volatility even when the score tightens dramatically.
Explore more NCAAF market analysis on SportChartz.